Skip to main content

Ryan Day should be coaching for his job on Saturday

Five losses without a rivalry win is a fireable offense.
ByGabe Emmert
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Ohio State has four regular-season losses, and they haven't even made it to the rivalry game yet. That is, of course, not anywhere near acceptable or up to standard at Ohio State. He won a national championship two seasons ago and has an incredible winning percentage, but Ryan Day is firmly on the hot seat going into next season. This administration doesn't seem to be in the mood to make a change at the head coach position, but they should be, and a loss to Michigan could make things untenable.

Record -wise, this is Ohio State's worst season since 2011, when they went 6-6 in the regular season, 3-5 in conference play, and lost to Florida in the Gator Bowl. That team had an interim head coach and was missing multiple key players due to some off-field issues. This team was the number one ranked team in the country in the AP preseason poll. Considering the expectations, this is Ohio State's worst season since at least 2000, which ended in a coaching change.

Ohio State wasted this season with how they played

Ryan Day has won a national championship, and even if the Michigan game is his last one, you could certainly argue that his Ohio State tenure has been a success. However, Ohio State was eliminated from Big Ten title contention with its loss to Nebraska.

Day has just two Big Ten titles in eight years, and Ohio State now has a seven-year conference title drought, its longest since its 14-year drought from 1921-1934. If they lose to Michigan on Saturday, Day's record against the Wolverines would be 2-5. For comparison, Ohio State had lost five games total against Michigan from 1997-2018.

Despite those shortcomings, Day's resume as the coach of the Buckeyes isn't the reason why the administration needs to consider moving on. It's the present and future. This is the least talented Ohio State football team in a long time.

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

They're probably only going to have one player drafted in the top 50 picks in this coming draft. All of their star talent is young, but those guys are going to need development to become players that can return Ohio State to the program standard. That development has been lacking at a lot of positions.

Changes are needed for the Ohio State football program

Due to the lack of development and missed evaluations in both recruiting and the portal, Ohio State is going to have to make big changes to the staff, whether Ryan Day is back or not. They already fired one coordinator; they're going to have to fire at least another one because Matt Patricia's failure to adapt completely cost the Buckeyes in Lincoln, and they might have to consider firing Arthur Smith as well. They're going to have to fire a handful of position coaches, and you could easily argue that every position coach except for James Lauranitis and Matt Guerrieri could be let go.

If the administration wants Ryan Day back, they cannot make that decision because they feel that he's earned it after winning a national title two years ago. They have to truly believe that he can turn it around.

Day has a $75 million buyout, but that number goes down drastically if he gets another job. Ohio State is in such a bad spot that they might have another rough season next year with or without Day. If they keep him for two more years and he goes, let's say 16-8 in those two years, it's going to be a lot harder for him to get another head coaching job.

I'm not sure how I feel about keeping or firing Ryan Day, but I do know that a lot needs to change. If you have to overhaul the coaching staff, the roster, and the program culture, all while changing the process in which you go about bringing in players, at what point do you just look back at the guy who runs the whole program? If they lose to Michigan for the fifth time in six years, their hand might be forced to make a move.

Add us as a preferred source on Google