Ohio State was left for dead after it suffered its third loss against the Oregon Ducks. Two weeks later, the Buckeyes have surged in the College Football Playoff rankings. That's just a few spots away from making the top 12. They still need a lot to happen, but crazier things have happened, and this has been one of the craziest seasons of college football that I can remember. Let's talk about how it can still happen.
Ohio State is ranked 14th in the most recent College Football Playoff rankings. The number 12 seed in the playoff is almost certainly going to go to the highest-ranked non-power-conference champion, meaning the Buckeyes need to finish in the top 11. That means they need to pass four teams. Let's break down the teams around the Buckeyes into tiers.
Too far ahead
Georgia, Utah, Alabama, UCLA, Texas, and Miami would all probably have to lose each of their final two games in order for Ohio State to have a chance to pass them. UCLA is probably the only one of those teams where finishing with back-to-back losses is possible, but if that happens, Ohio State would likely be in the Big Ten Championship game, while UCLA wouldn't. I think the committee would put the Bruins ahead and make the Buckeyes earn it in Indianapolis.
Questionable cases
Two teams that I can't quite get a grip on as to how they compare to OSU with a loss are Notre Dame and Tennessee. Notre Dame finishes with SMU at home and Syracuse on the road. Either of those would be a pretty bad loss for an Irish team that has just one big win, over Miami by seven points without their best player and the air of a controversial call.
As for Tennessee, if they lose a game, it would be very close between the Buckeyes and the Volunteers. Tennessee finishes with LSU at home and Vanderbilt on the road. If they lose to a bad Vanderbilt team, that would probably favor OSU. If they lose to LSU, Tennessee probably gets that spot due to their 16-point win over Alabama, which the committee clearly values very highly.
Head-to-head oddities
There are four teams near Ohio State in the rankings that they played. There isn't much controversy with Oregon. They are ahead of Ohio State now, and that won't change unless the Ducks lose. The same can be said on the opposite side for Iowa.
Despite having one fewer loss, the Hawkeyes are behind the Buckeyes because of their head-to-head loss and having no ranked wins. I think USC, which is ranked behind Ohio State, would finish ahead of the Buckeyes if they both win out.
The reason for this is that the Trojans have a huge resume booster on their schedule, as they end the season against UCLA in Pasadena. At that point, I think the Trojans' 12-point victory over the Buckeyes would carry the day.
The complicated team here is Indiana. If the Hoosiers finish 10-2 and the Buckeyes finish 9-3, who gets that spot? Ohio State beat Indiana in Bloomington, but IU was a few inches of foot placement away from winning that game.
You could argue, as Curt Cignetti has, that Ohio State is a different team now without Julian Sayin, but that game was by far the worst game that Sayin has played as a Buckeye. The Hoosiers are the defending national champions, which isn't supposed to matter because this is a new season, but the committee members are human, just like the rest of us.
I also wonder if the Hoosiers' non-conference schedule will hold them back, considering that the Buckeyes challenged themselves with a trip to Austin and lost by just one point to a good Texas team.
Teams that need to lose
Some quick math first. If six teams are certainly ahead of the Buckeyes, and there are three that I'm unsure of, that means there could be as little as two spots left to claim. Ohio State will need as many of the following teams to lose as they can: BYU, Oregon, Texas Tech, USC, and Wake Forest.
They will likely need at least four of those five teams to lose. Here are each of those teams' schedules and the probability of each of them losing out according to ESPN's FPI.
BYU's final two games are at Kansas and at home against Cincinnati. There is a 26.8% chance they lose one of those games.
Oregon's final two games are at Michigan State and at home against Washington. There is a 25.2% chance they lose one of those games.
Texas Tech's final two games are at Baylor and at home against TCU. There is a 51.2% chance they lose one of those games.
USC's final two games are at home against Maryland and at UCLA. There is a 54.4% chance they lose one of those games.
Wake Forest's final two games are at Georgia Tech and at home against Duke. There is a 30.25% chance they lose one of those games.
Let's say Oregon wins out, because they have the best chance to do so based on FPI. There is about a 2.3% chance that the other four teams all lose a game. Ohio State fans were all excited to see them at 14th in the most recent rankings, but that's a really low number.
The odds might be a little better than that because Indiana or Notre Dame or Tennessee could lose, and maybe the committee decides to pick Ohio State in that case, but they also need one more thing. If these teams in front of them lose, that would mean Utah would need to win the Big 12, and Miami would need to win the ACC. Those two teams would both make the CFP even with losses in their conference title games, and then the winners of those games could steal Ohio State's spot.
This has been a disappointing season in Columbus so far. There is no way around that. A playoff appearance doesn't mean changes aren't desperately needed, but as long as the Buckeyes have a chance, it is worth rooting for. I just hope that I'm not writing a similar article next season about how the Buckeyes can still sneak into the 24-team playoff.

